Why Does God Allow Suffering? Wrestling with the Unknown

One Lesson About Suffering You May Never Know Why

0:00

/867.904

Suffering has a way of turning us into investigators.

When something painful enters our lives, we begin searching for answers. We replay conversations, revisit decisions, examine circumstances, and look for something we might have missed. Why did this happen? Could I have prevented it? Did I make the wrong decision? Is God trying to teach me something?

And perhaps the question beneath all the others: Why would God allow this?

I've asked those questions more times than I can count. There is something comforting about believing that if we could understand the reason behind our suffering, somehow it would become easier to carry. We imagine that an explanation might bring peace, that if we could connect all the dots, the pain would finally make sense.

We approach suffering much like we approach other problems in life. When a car breaks down, we want to know which part failed. When we become sick, we want a diagnosis. When a relationship falls apart, we replay conversations, searching for the moment everything began to change.

Understanding gives us a sense of control. If we can identify the problem, perhaps we can fix it. If we know what caused it, maybe we can prevent it from happening again.

But suffering introduces questions that knowledge alone cannot answer.

A doctor may explain exactly what happened inside someone's body. That explanation can guide treatment and prepare us for what comes next. But it doesn't necessarily answer the question keeping a parent awake at night.

Why my child?

There is a difference between understanding how something happened and understanding why it was allowed to happen.

I think part of our struggle is that we want suffering to have an explanation proportionate to the pain it causes. The greater the loss, the greater our need for an answer. We want to know that the pain wasn't meaningless, that God sees what we're experiencing, and that He hasn't forgotten us.

Sometimes our search for answers becomes a search for something we could have done differently. We revisit decisions, question our judgment, and wonder whether one small change might have prevented everything. But there are circumstances we simply could not have controlled, no matter how carefully we tried. And when we carry responsibility for things that were never within our power, we add another burden to an already painful experience.

Sometimes we recognize something good that came out of a terrible experience. Other times, years pass and the questions remain.

One of the hardest lessons I've learned about suffering is this:

Sometimes the explanation never comes.

The Question God Didn't Answer

The book of Job has become increasingly meaningful to me because it confronts our desire for answers in a way that few other passages do.

Job is introduced as a man who fears God and turns away from evil. He has a family, possessions, and a life that appears secure. Then, in a devastating series of events, nearly everything is taken from him.

His livestock are destroyed or stolen. His servants are killed. His children die. His health deteriorates until he is sitting among ashes, scraping his painful sores with broken pottery.

Think about the shock of losing nearly everything familiar in such a short period of time. The overwhelming grief, the physical suffering, and the questions that must have consumed him.

Job's friends arrive, and initially they do something remarkable. They sit with him in silence for seven days because his suffering is so great. For an entire week, their presence speaks louder than anything they could say.

But eventually, they begin talking.

Their reasoning is straightforward: God is just, so Job must have done something to deserve his suffering. Somewhere in his life, they assume, there must be a sin that explains his circumstances. The longer they speak, the more their explanations become accusations.

Job insists that their conclusions are wrong. He knows he isn't perfect, but he has not committed some hidden wrongdoing that accounts for these disasters.

What makes the book so remarkable is that we, the readers, know something Job and his friends don't.

The opening chapters allow us to see a heavenly conversation involving God and Satan. Satan challenges Job's faithfulness, suggesting that Job serves God only because his life has been blessed. God permits Job to be tested, though Satan is given limits. This glimpse reveals that Job's suffering is not punishment for the secret wrongdoing his friends keep insisting must exist.

Even this glimpse doesn't explain why God allows suffering, and the book never offers it as a formula for explaining anyone else's pain.

But Job never receives that perspective.

He doesn't know about the conversation in heaven. From his position, he sees only the destruction of the life he once knew, and he desperately wants an answer.

When God Finally Speaks

After chapter upon chapter of arguments, accusations, grief, and questions, God finally responds.

Imagine Job's anticipation. After everything he has experienced, after all the questions he has asked, the Lord speaks from the whirlwind.

Surely now Job will understand.

But God's response is unexpected.

"Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth? Tell me, if you have understanding."

— Job 38:4, ESV

God begins asking Job questions about creation. He speaks about the foundations of the earth, the boundaries of the sea, the movement of the stars, and creatures living beyond human observation.

At first, it almost seems as though God is changing the subject. Job has been asking about suffering, and God is talking about the universe.

But consider what God is revealing.

Job has been trying to understand his circumstances from the only perspective available to him. God begins showing him just how much exists beyond that perspective. The world is far larger, more intricate, and more complex than Job can comprehend.

Even the ordinary processes of creation involve realities beyond his knowledge and control. Job is encountering the difference between human understanding and divine wisdom.

And here's something that stands out to me:

God answers Job, but He never gives him the explanation Job was searching for.

I realize this may not feel like a satisfying answer. When someone is suffering deeply, being reminded of how little they understand may seem to offer little comfort. But Job's encounter reveals something beyond the limits of human knowledge. The God who speaks from the whirlwind is the same God who would one day enter human suffering through Jesus Christ. His wisdom extends beyond our understanding, and His compassion is revealed in the One who came to suffer alongside us and for us.

Job eventually responds:

"I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you."

— Job 42:5, ESV

Something profound has happened. Job's understanding of God has deepened through an encounter that reaches beyond the answers he originally sought.

God then rebukes Job's friends for speaking wrongly about Him. Their confident explanations had misrepresented God's dealings with Job.

Afterward, the book closes with God restoring Job's fortunes and blessing the latter part of his life. Yet those blessings do not make his earlier losses insignificant. The children he buried were real people he loved. The grief he experienced was real.

The good that follows does not erase the grief that remains.

Be Careful When Explaining Someone Else's Pain

There's another lesson in Job's story that I think deserves our attention.

When we encounter suffering, especially someone else's, we often feel compelled to say something meaningful. We want to help, encourage, and remind the person that God is still working. Those desires can come from a sincere place, but in our eagerness to provide comfort, we can sometimes offer explanations Scripture hasn't given us.

We might tell someone that God allowed their tragedy to teach them patience, strengthen their marriage, redirect their career, or prepare them for a future ministry.

God is certainly capable of bringing growth and unexpected opportunities through painful circumstances. He can redeem even the most difficult experiences. Yet recognizing what God accomplishes through suffering is different from knowing why He permitted a particular event.

We should be careful about claiming to know God's specific purposes when He has not revealed them.

Jesus addressed a similar assumption in John 9. When His disciples encountered a man born blind, they asked whether the man's blindness resulted from his sin or his parents' sin.

They were looking for an explanation.

Jesus rejected both explanations and revealed that the works of God would be displayed in this man's life. Jesus knew what the disciples could not see, and He spoke with authority about what God was about to accomplish.

That distinction matters. Jesus could reveal God's purpose in this particular circumstance because He knew it. We should approach the suffering of others with greater humility, recognizing that we rarely possess that same understanding.

Sometimes the most meaningful thing we can offer a suffering person is our presence. A meal, a conversation, a prayer, or a willingness to sit beside them without trying to make sense of everything.

Job's friends were at their best when they were simply sitting with him.

Not every question needs an immediate answer. And not every hurting person needs an explanation.

Sometimes they need someone willing to stay.

Standing Inside a Single Chapter

Imagine opening a novel somewhere in the middle. You haven't read the opening chapters, met all the characters, or learned the events that brought them to this point. You read a few pages, trying to piece together a story you only partially understand.

Now imagine that you're living inside those pages.

The circumstances are real. The decisions have consequences. The people involved are people you love, and you cannot turn ahead to see how it ends.

That's much closer to our experience of suffering.

We see the diagnosis, the relationship that fell apart, the job that disappeared, or the prayer that seems unanswered. We experience these things one day at a time, trying to make sense of what is happening with only the information available to us.

We are trying to understand an entire story while standing inside a single chapter.

Sometimes, as life unfolds, we recognize ways God has worked through our circumstances, even when the suffering itself remains difficult to understand.

Other questions may stay with us for the rest of our lives.

And learning to live with that uncertainty can be one of the most difficult parts of suffering.

When the Answers Don't Come

One of the things I appreciate about Scripture is how openly it portrays human suffering.

The Psalms are filled with questions, lament, frustration, and grief. David cries out, "How long, O LORD? Will you forget me forever?" (Psalm 13:1, ESV). Habakkuk asks why God seems to tolerate injustice, while Jeremiah expresses profound anguish over his circumstances.

Even Jesus, suffering on the Cross, cries out with the opening words of Psalm 22: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Matthew 27:46, ESV).

These expressions of anguish have been preserved in Scripture, and they tell me something important about our relationship with God.

We can bring our questions into His presence. We can tell Him that we're confused, afraid, angry, disappointed, or exhausted. We can acknowledge that something hurts, that we're struggling to understand, and that we desperately want things to change.

And we can keep asking Him to intervene.

In the garden of Gethsemane, Jesus prayed:

"Father, if you are willing, remove this cup from me."

— Luke 22:42, ESV

Jesus brought His desire before the Father while surrendering Himself to the Father's will. His example gives us a picture of prayer that is both honest and trusting.

We can pray for healing. We can ask God to restore what has been damaged, rescue someone we love, or change circumstances that seem impossible. We can bring those requests to Him again tomorrow, even if we've been praying the same prayer for months or years.

Trusting God with an unknown outcome doesn't mean we stop asking Him for the outcome we desperately hope for.

There may also be seasons when our prayers sound less like confident declarations and more like a desperate request:

Lord, I don't understand what's happening. I don't know what You're doing. But I need You to help me through today.

That is a prayer worth praying, too.

And when the answers don't come, we can look to what God has already revealed about Himself.

We see the compassion of Jesus, who wept beside a grieving family even though He knew He was about to raise Lazarus from the dead.

We see the Cross, where God entered human suffering through His Son and accomplished redemption through an event that appeared, to those watching, to be a devastating defeat.

And we have the promise of Romans 8 that hardship, danger, and even death cannot separate those who belong to Christ from His love.

These truths remind us of the character of the One to whom we bring our questions.

I don't have to understand everything God allows in order to trust what He has revealed about Himself.

Perhaps that's where peace begins—in learning that we can remain close to God while mysteries remain.

One Step Forward

Proverbs 3:5 says:

"Trust in the LORD with all your heart, and do not lean on your own understanding."

— Proverbs 3:5, ESV

We naturally lean on what we understand. We draw confidence from information, explanations, plans, and predictable outcomes. When those things disappear, we discover how much of our security depended upon them.

Trusting God with all our hearts means learning to rely upon Him even when our understanding reaches its limits.

Maybe today that looks like praying again. Maybe it means releasing yourself from the responsibility of explaining something you could never have controlled. Maybe it's allowing yourself to grieve without feeling obligated to turn your pain into an inspirational story.

Or perhaps it's simply getting up tomorrow and doing the next thing God has placed before you.

You may never know why certain things happened in your life. But your unanswered questions do not have to become the end of your relationship with God.

There are chapters of our lives we may never fully understand on this side of eternity. Yet Scripture gives us hope that reaches beyond our present circumstances.

Revelation 21:4 promises a day when God will wipe away every tear, and death, mourning, crying, and pain will be no more. Paul reminds us in 1 Corinthians 13:12 that our understanding is partial now, but a day is coming when we will see with greater clarity.

We may not know how every chapter fits together, but we know that suffering will not write the final one.

Until then, we live with questions, trusting the character of the One who holds our future.

You don't need to see the whole path. You can trust God with what you cannot understand—and take one step forward.

Join the Conversation

Have you ever experienced a season when you had to move forward without understanding why something happened? What helped you continue trusting God?

I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

Take Your Next Step

Looking for more encouragement as you grow in your faith?

Explore the One Step Forward Resource Library, where you'll find free and affordable Bible studies designed to help you draw closer to God and apply His Word to everyday life.

Explore the Bible Studies & Resources